| Corpses
have a funny way of clarifying things.
On July 20th,
an Italian policeman shot and killed a man named Carlo Giuliani during
a fierce scuffle between demonstrators and authorities at the Group of
8 summit in Genoa, attended by the leaders of the seven wealthiest nations,
Russia, and, this year, 100,000 protestors.
Make that
99,999.
Giuliani
was no saint -- hes said to have had various weapons charges on
his record, and he went down hurling a fire extinguisher like a mortar
shell at police -- but his death promises to mark a turning point for
the world-wide movement gathered under the catch-all banner of anti-globalization.
The ages
of Giuliani and the policeman who shot him -- 23 and 20 -- remind us that
both were mere foot soldiers in a much larger struggle. What was at stake
in Genoa -- and, since the Battle of Seattle two years ago, similar showdowns
in Washington, Prague, Quebec, and a dozen other cities -- isnt
simply the shape of economics. Its the nature of belief in the new
millennium.
Writing in
the New York Times, Thomas Friedman called those opposed to the
expansion of globalization "flat-earthers" who dont know
which way the wind is blowing. In a strange mix of hubris and apparent
resignation, Friedman and other globalizers insist that A) we now have
the technology and the political wisdom to bring benign capitalism to
everyone on the planet, with democracy following in its wake; and B) this
transformation is a fact of life. Get used to it.
Like the
globalists, the anti-globalists stake their cause on a blend of humanism
with factors so incalculable they might as well be divine. They declare
that globalization isnt inevitable, but the result of a concerted
effort by the wealthiest to distract everyone else with a few crumbs.
In exchange
for opening all borders to corporations, for instance, the World Bank
offers an indirect percentage of the profits to local governments in power.
Let First World corporations do business, and well help you afford
their products; make way for McDonalds, and well buy you a
burger.
But even
with a dash of compassion laissez-faire economics wont end poverty,
argue anti-globalists -- social justice will. No matter that "justice"
is a vague and relative concept. The point is that its a work-in-progress,
not a done deal. It cant be planned so much as struggled for.
The differences
in these worldviews are beyond compromise. Between the alleged logic of
free market true believers and the passion of heretics in the street there
exists not only a political disagreement but a fundamental theological
divide.
On one hand
we have the globalists and their high priests: bankers and diplomats executing
natures plan, the process that cant be stopped. On the other,
the many prophets of anti-globalization: environmental druids, anarchist
ninjas, union organizers, policy grinders, pacifists, political prisoners,
poor people, and squatters like Carlo Giuliani -- a vast array opposed
for various reasons to the neo-liberal attempt to enclose all that is
alive and mysterious in a set of trade agreements and holding corporations.
Globalists
speak openly of inevitability, the manifest destiny of capitalism: "The
future is now." Anti-globalists respond with a chorus of uncertainty
that ranges from hopeful to nihilist. The future, they say, is just that
-- something that awaits us, something we can help make, something still
to come.
Both groups
are at their core utopian. Globalists believe that capitalism has enabled
them to seize the divine fire. Anti-globalists counter that genetically-altered
tomatoes, dammed-up rivers, and a universal language called commerce wont
bring us any closer to heaven on earth.
Both groups
call on the memory of dystopia. After a century of massive war and genocide,
of communism and fascism, globalists claim that weve reached the
"end of history." The Berlin Wall has crumbled. Capitalism alone
remains standing -- the one true god. Anti-globalists, meanwhile, believe
that the 20th centurys lesson is one of humility. They dream not
of the brave new world preached by communists, fascists, or capitalists,
but of many small worlds and a pantheon of deities, both supernatural
and scientific.
Neither group
speaks often of religion, but both use the rhetoric of faith -- inevitability,
the unknowable, the sacred (nature, in the broadest sense of the term,
for the anti-globalists; the "invisible hand" for the globalists)
and the profane (poverty, in the view of both groups).
Thus far,
theyve managed to avoid the language of martyrdom -- which is bound
to escalate the conflict to a degree frightening to pacifists on both
sides. But now that will change. Men and women have died in the globalization
struggle already, but the shot that killed Carlo Giuliani in Genoa seems
to be the one heard around the world, echoing through the pages of newspapers
all over the planet.
Last Friday,
Giuliani fell outside a barricade erected to keep demonstrators away from
the summit. On one side of his body were the G-8 leaders, certain that
the future is theirs. On the other stood 99,999 angry demonstrators, sure
of only one thing -- the first fatality in a holy war lay before them.
|